The Promise and the Problem of Video Surveillance
Public Surveillance: Crime Scene Documentation / Criminal Identification
When crimes - from terrorist bombings to broken windows and torched cars on the edge of mass demonstrations to criminals acting independently - occur in public spaces, investigators need the ability to view video footage to help identify perpetrators. Ubiquitous high-quality cameras have a role in solving and deterring crime. A good list of proposed justice-system reforms (here is one) includes a light touch on crowd control at public demonstrations in concert with aggressive response to any violence – as part of permitting, organizers must acknowledge that the proceedings are monitored by city cameras as well as those of the participants. But what of privacy? And what keeps a city employee from tracking someone through video recordings for reasons having nothing to do with solving or deterring crime?
Private Surveillance
Video surveillance of workplaces, retail spaces and apartment or condo buildings by the property owner help to keep the spaces safe. Again, ubiquitous high-quality cameras have a role in solving and deterring crime. But how can workers, shoppers, and residents be assured that they're not spied upon for reasons having nothing to do with safety?
Deferred Surveillance
Safeguarding people against potential criminals and surveillance abuse can be done with deferred surveillance. By this we mean: